The Balanced Man

Den balanserade mannen

We talk a great deal about what it means to be a man today. About men who have lost their direction, men who are too hard and men who have become too soft. The conversation often ends with one way of being declared right and the other wrong. Carl Jung offered a different way of looking at it, and I find it more useful than almost anything else I have read on the subject. In his view, imbalance arises when one side of a man is left to rule alone, whichever side that happens to be.

The inner counterpart

Jung saw that every person carries both a driving and a receiving force. The driving force takes the initiative, sets the direction, makes decisions and protects. The receiving force feels, listens, weaves things together and lets them grow at their own pace.

In a man, the driving side is usually the one he identifies with, the one he has learned to be. The receiving side lives on in the unconscious, and Jung called this inner figure the anima. She is feeling, intuition and the capacity for closeness, everything a boy is often told he should grow out of.

The anima does not disappear because a man pretends she is not there. Either she is given a place in his life, or she steers him from the shadows. That is where imbalance begins.

The man in balance

The balanced man has not given up either side of himself. He can take the initiative and carry responsibility without hesitating, and he lets feeling guide his decisions without letting it take them over.

In everyday life it shows in small things. He listens without rushing to fix. He says what he is carrying, openly and with respect. He looks after his relationships because he cares, not out of duty. He has goals and works towards them with persistence, yet he needs no constant reassurance to feel that he is enough.

He can show vulnerability without feeling weak, and he can make a difficult decision without first being completely sure. He cries openly at his daughter's graduation, and two weeks later he leaves a job that has worn him down for years.

Balance takes nothing away from him. He does not lose his drive by becoming emotionally present. What changes is how the parts work together. For the first time, he has access to all of himself.

When feeling takes the helm

The first imbalance is the one we least expect to find in a man. Here the anima has been given too much power, and he is ruled by feelings, fantasies and idealised images. He struggles to stay grounded when reality does not live up to what he carries inside.

He can be swept away by a new person or a new idea with an intensity out of all proportion to how little he knows them. Each time he is sure that this time it is real, and just as quickly he loses interest once the image cracks.

Conflict, structure and decisions become hard, because he first has to feel his way through everything, endlessly. In relationships he may come to depend on his partner to regulate his own emotions, while finding it hard to take the responsibility such closeness asks of him. The Jungian analyst Marie-Louise von Franz gave an extreme form of this pattern a name, the puer aeternus, the eternal boy: charming and gifted, yet never quite present in his own life.

The way out does not ask him to switch off the feeling that makes him who he is. He needs to learn to carry it himself for a while, before handing it to the next person who catches his eye.

When feeling shuts down

The second imbalance is far more common, and it is hard to spot because it often looks like strength. Here the man has lost touch with his anima. He becomes rational, goal-driven and emotionally closed, often because that is exactly what he learned a man should be.

He finds it hard to feel and to put words to what he carries. Closeness becomes awkward, and vulnerability, his own or anyone else's, is met with sharpness or irritation. His relationships look stable from the outside but grow thin on the inside. His body's signals are ignored until they can no longer be ignored.

Picture a man in his forties with a growing business, three children, a beautiful house and strength training three times a week. Everything looks like success. Yet a restlessness creeps in. He becomes irritable, drinks a little more wine in the evenings and sleeps worse and worse. Ask him how he is and he says he is tired, because he has never learned to ask who he is when he is not performing.

In its most hardened form this becomes what Jungians call the punishing patriarch: the boss who rules through fear, the parent who demands obedience without warmth. Even there, no malice lies behind it, only a force that was once needed to survive and has since set hard.

The way back

Neither of these imbalances is a flaw in the man who carries it. They are patterns that once served a purpose, perhaps to get through a childhood, a relationship or a culture that only made room for one side. And patterns can be unlearned.

For the man ruled by his feelings, the way back is about finding a steady point within himself. For the man who has shut down, it is about daring to feel, often for the first time in a long while. In both cases the goal is the same: that both sides get to speak, and that neither silences the other.

Do you recognise yourself, your partner, your father or your son in any of this? Then I want you to know what is also the title of my book: there is nothing wrong with you, you are just out of balance.

In my book There Is Nothing Wrong With You. You Are Just Out of Balance. I go deeper into how imbalance shows itself in both men and women, in the body, in our relationships and in society, and what waits on the other side. It is available in paperback, as an ebook and as an audiobook.